From Island to Island, pt 2

This is a continuation of this post.

Scollay emigration

Scollays of Yell

Robert SCOLLAY was born on October 2, 1834, in Vatsetter, Shetland to Daniel SCOLLAY and Barbara Jane PETRIE. The eldest of 6 children, Robert followed his father into becoming a merchant seaman.

His brothers and sisters were all born between 1838 and 1853. His father died in 1860, at sea, off the coast of Shetland along with his brother, William. Following his death, Daniel’s widow Barbara received a merchant seaman’s pension and remained on Vatsetter, working as a Farmer, Knitter, and Crofter.

Ruins of house, Vatsetter, Yell, Shetland [1]

Shetland to Australia, a mariner’s life

Robert is listed in the Registry of Shipping and Seamen: Alphabetical Index of Registers of Seamen’s Tickets with Register Ticket number 557791, however no definitive record of his registry entry can be found. There is an entry in the 1853-1857 Registry for a “Robert Soollay” of Shetland. The age of the man corresponds and the note “Nord Isles Lerwick” corresponds with the region. In this record, the man went to sea on 1 November 1854 for a P. Byron of Glasgow and did not have a “home” entry in the log.
According to various sources, Robert was an officer on a ship travelling to Australia in 1859 when he met Margaret REIDY/READ/REED (daughter of Colonel John or Cornelius REIDY/READ/REED of the British Army). They married in Melbourne.

Records for the birth of one of Robert’s children in Australia are found (in Sandridge, Victoria, now Port Melbourne), however, arrival records and marriage records are not found with certainty. This is made more difficult by the uncertainty of Margaret’s actual surname. According to a family tree published on Bayanne and Wikitree, the dates and places of birth of all of Robert and Margaret’s children are known, but this is not fully referenced on either site. Owners of both trees have been contacted asking for further information, but no responses have been received.

Logging, Ship Building, Fishing and Stewart Island

Halfmoon Bay, near Oban, Stewart Island [2]

Robert and his family arrived in New Zealand in 1861 on the ship Queen of Perth. He came to Stewart Island with saw-milling timber and a complete saw-mill plant as he was under engagement to erect the first saw-mill on the island. Robert was also involved in the fishing industry, was a pioneer of the oyster business and ran his own schooner on the coast until 1899.

Robert Scollay’s ship ‘Enterprise’ under construction c.1874 [3]

Robert built a total of eight ships:

Ship Name Notes
LerwickCutter. Used for oyster fishing. Ran aground 15 July 1875.
Jane Scollay Schooner. Replacement for Lerwick lost the year before.
Unknown Cutter. Used in summer for tourism. Oil engine and propellor driven.
Margaret Scollay Schooner. Used for trade between Stewart Island, Bluff, Invercargill and Dunedin.
Endeavour Founded at moorings at South Pegasus
EclipseWrecked at Stewart Island.
Dauntless
EnterpriseUsed by Captain Catling to attempt to recover the gold of the General Grant at Auckland Islands.

To improve the fishing industry in New Zealand, immigration agents targeted Shetlanders. In June 1873, a group of thirty-one migrants recruited specifically for this purpose were carried to Stewart Island.

Horses Hauling Logs, Maori Beach, Stewart Island [4]

The logging industry was important to the development of Stewart Island and the discovery of tin in the late 1800s started a “tin rush” in the south of the island. Robert was involved in the establishment of tin mining.

Land Owner

In New Zealand, Shetlanders were drawn in the 1860s to the south-east, especially Dunedin in Otago, and Stewart Island.

Ian Tait, Shetland Museum and Archives [5]
Bravo Island Settlement, 1879. (Located in Paterson Inlet, Stewart Island). Used with permission of Alexander Turnbull Library. [6]

Robert arrived on Steward Island with his wife and three children in 1861. In 1864 he settled at Half Moon Bay and established a successful skippering trade, transporting people to and from the mainland, as well as to nearby islands. One of his boats was named ‘Lerwick’, a throw-back to his Shetland heritage. He built the boarding house Bayview and established his boatyard in front of the property.

Bayview Boarding House, Oban, Stewart Island [7]

Legacy and Conclusion

An influential member of society, Scollay Rocks and Scollay Flat were named after Robert and he was referred to, in one of his obituaries, as the “Patriarch of Stewart Island” . Along with his boat building, fishing and timber activities, Robert was a member of the Stewart Island school committee; a member of the Southland League and a lay preacher of the non-denominational church at Halfmoon Bay.

Advertisement for Bay View House, Stewart Island, 1887 [9]

‘Scotsmen are proverbially inclined to roam abroad in quest of fortune.’ [12]

Whether this is a generalisation or rings true is a subject of debate for historians. However, the success of Robert Scollay in New Zealand, compared to his prospects had he remained in Shetland, suggests this may be somewhat accurate.

Public notice of intention to use an oyster bed at Stewart Island, 1869 [10]
Notification of grant of 20 acres, Stewart Island, 1875 [11]

This report has provided a brief snapshot of the life of this man, and how emigration impacted and shaped his life. It is a similar story to that of other immigrant ancestors, particularly in my family. Being Australian, I have several convict ancestors, however, those who chose to emigrate often found their fortunes improved from when they were “back home”.

A curious document is available in the New Zealand Archives which may provide further information into the activities and fortunes of Robert Scollay. Found in the Dunedin Bankruptcy Files for 1877, a document for a SCOLLAY Robert of Stewart Island who was a Master Mariner can be accessed on-site at the NZ Archives in Dunedin (Item ID: R19947809).

An article entitled “On the Metal – The Tin Miners of Port Pegasus”, published in New Zealand Geographic, makes mention of Robert Scollay and his involvement as a ship captain, land and smithy owner and prospector during the NZ “tin rush” in the 1880s. This article provides some interesting titbits about Robert’s activities and may warrant further investigation.

The changing fortunes of migrants from Scotland has undoubtedly been researched by many historians, but the application of genealogical research and the telling of individual stories helps enrichen our understanding of just how impactful this phenomenon was – both on the economy of the target land but also the lives of the people involved and their descendants.

Sign for Scollay Rocks, named for Robert. [8]

[1] Images: Photograph. Ruins of house, Vatsetter, Yell, Shetland. Date June 2009. Photographer unknown. Google. http://maps.google.co.uk

[2] Images: Photograph. Halfmoon Bay and Paterson’s Inlet, Stewart Island, New Zealand. Date and photographer unknown. Te Ara. http://www.teara.govt.nz/en/stewart-islandrakiura

[3] Images: Photograph. Ship ‘Enterprise’ under construction, Oban, Stewart Island. Date 1873/74. Photographer unknown. Stewart Island News, August 2006. http://www.stewartislandnews.com/uploads/5/3/5/0/53500577/july_2006.pdf

[4] Images: Photograph. Horses Hauling Logs, Maori Beach, Stewart Island. Date unknown. Photographer: E.A. Phillips. Stewart Island – Island of Tranquility. http://www.stewartisland.co.nz/pages/heritage/

[5] Shetland News. 2010. Emigrants’ tales captured. http://www.shetnews.co.uk/news/2865-emigrants-tales-captured

[6] Images: Painting. Bravo Island Settlement. Date: 1879. Artist: Christopher Aubrey. NZ History. https://nzhistory.govt.nz/media/photo/bravo-island-settlement

[7] Images: Photograph. Bayview Boarding House, Oban, Stewart Island. Date and photographer unknown. Stewart Island News, August 2009. http://www.stewartislandnews.com/uploads/5/3/5/0/53500577/august_2009.pdf

[8] Images: Photograph. Scollay Rocks Sign, Oban, Stewart Island. Date: 2016. Photographer: Emmeline [surname unknown]. https://emmelementsmiscellany.wordpress.com/

[9] Public Notices. Evening Star. 26 November 1887. https://paperspast.natlib.govt.nz/newspapers/ESD18871126.2.30.2

[10] Advertisements Column. Southland Times. 22 November 1869. https://paperspast.natlib.govt.nz/newspapers/ST18691122.2.12.3

[11] Waste Lands Board. Southland Times. 13 January 1875. https://paperspast.natlib.govt.nz/newspapers/ST18750113.2.8

[12] Chambers’s Edinburgh Journal, No. 302, October 1849, p.225. http://www.archive.org/stream/chamberssedinbu06chamgoog#page/n655

Family History or Time Travel?

When I was younger, and getting to know people (generally boys or girls I was attracted to and wanted to woo), I would give them a list of 20 questions and ask them to answer them all. It would either be done in person, on the phone, via a letter or more recently, via email/chat. These questions would be all about getting to know the other person better, find commonality and hopefully present myself as somewhat mysterious, enigmatic and far more intellectual than I am.



Which time period would you most like to live in and why?

Very important question I would ask people I fancy

My answer to that question would often depend on their answer (because, remember, I was trying to get them to fancy me, so I had to be as similar to them as possible. Yay, psychology!) and I’d say anything from “Ancient Egypt” to “200 years in the future”. I wasn’t really thinking about it. Sure, I was interested, but my answer was generally not genuine.

Being a genealogist, I get to look into the lives of so many different people, from different backgrounds, places and times. Whilst most of the research I do is in the British Isles, one county to the next can provide completely different customs, events and names. Add time to this and these lands present an immeasurable amount of genealogical and historical variety.

Looking at the rest of my family and where they’re from, we need to add Australia, New Zealand, South Africa, Sweden, Norway, Germany and Eastern Europe into the mix.



Gold miner’s cottage at Hill End, NSW, Australia. Photograph: Bernard Holtermann

To pose that question to myself today means I need to really sit back and think. Sure, I could answer something glib like “Oooh, the roaring twenties” or “the middle ages” – but what does that really mean? When we think of those two eras, in particular, we probably think of Flappers and Knights/Damsels, respectively. But we know that to think of an era in such a simplistic manner is to completely gloss over what was really going on then and what life would be like were I to time travel and spend the rest of my days there.


Would I be able to ignore my modern way of thinking and take on board the beliefs and desires of people in the 19th century?


Would I want to live in Shetland in the 1800s, when my ancestor, Robert Scollay, was forced to leave and travel to New Zealand due to poor economic opportunity, land clearances, and agricultural failures? What would it be like experiencing poverty, uncertainty and fear? Would I want to get on a ship to travel to the other side of the world – not knowing what I would encounter, and knowing I would never see my family again?

Would I be a strong pioneer in New Zealand? Would I be able to build a life from nothing. Find land, build a home, scrounge together a living from whatever I could do or find?

Would I want to do the same with my ancestors in Australia? Could I force first peoples from their land in order to build colonies of New South Wales, Victoria or Van Diemen’s Land? Would I keep my head down and ignore what was going on around me? Would I be able to ignore my modern way of thinking and take on board the beliefs and desires of people in the 19th century?

Or perhaps I’d like to travel to Sweden in the 16th century? Live and learn about life and the seasons with my family in Västra Götaland and Skåne. Spend my days on the farm with the cows and sheep and work from dawn to dusk helping to maintain the household?


Robert the Bruce facial reconstruction

I could go to another time, the 13th century, back to Scotland, and the Bruce clan, with my ancestor Matilda and her brother, Robert, who would become known as Robert the Bruce. What would my life be like as the daughter of a Baron and Countess? Living in a land in turmoil, with in-fighting and threats from England? Knowing that my position and life could be used to determine the course of political and personal life for so many in the land?

These are questions I now often ask myself when I am doing research (for myself or clients) and it is why I find it so terribly important to put as much context into my research as possible. Looking at my tree while I write this article, I see so many names, so many dates with lifespans, marriages, and other events. They are all part of who I am and have created a legacy that will last, but who were they? Really?

Family history is time travel. We don’t need a magic spell or a set of standing stones to be able to go back through the years and discover what life was like. We can find so much information from our ancestors and incredible research done by so many genealogists and historians. Adding to this body of research is so important and will be invaluable to future generations. I am proud to be a part of it, and vow to do more.

From this point, when I go over previous research or do further research into my ancestors, I will not move on to another generation until I have exhausted all possible avenues and repositories of information for the people in the current generation being researched. I want to create the story of how my family became to be and that starts with the families that went before.

I will be reproducing some of that research here, and in the coming months will be publishing papers on my ancestors from Shetland, along with information about the people over the years who lived in one house in Sussex.

(A huge thank you to Janet Few for inspiring this article.)